My rebbetzin and I are toying with the idea of me teaching a Jewish book class/leading a Jewish book discussion group at shul. Naturally I’m beyond thrilled at the possibility. Me? Leading discussions on Jewish books? How great a fit is that?
As soon as she mentioned the idea to me I started working on the list of books that I’d potentially like to have the class read. I share the list with her yesterday and thought I’d shared it here as well.
Ok so here are the 11 books that I had on my list as possibilities for the potential Jewish reading group. Some are traditional, some are the furthest thing from traditional, some are novels and some are non-fiction. The only common denominator (other than being Jewish related) is that I think all of them would be great jumping off points for some really interesting discussions.
Yentl’s Revenge: The Next Wave of Jewish Feminism
A provocative collection of impassioned essays by an unorthodox group of young Jewish feminists. The 20 writers wrestle with a wide range of issues from mainstream concerns like identity and Zionism, to edgier ones such as witchcraft and transgender theory. Particularly challenging is Haviva Ner-David’s “Parenting as a Religious Jewish Feminist.” Having grown up feeling “marginalized and irrelevant,” Ner-David is now studying with an Orthodox rabbi in Jerusalem for rabbinic ordination. She prays with the male accouterments of phylacteries and prayer shawl, and has taken part in other traditionally male rituals. Attuned to the discomfort she produces in other observant Jews, she expresses ambivalence about imposing her customs on her daughters. Loolwa Khazzoom, a Jew of Iraqi descent, describes the alienation she felt sitting behind the women’s prayer partition and in the face of condescension from Jews of European descent. Like the other writers here, instead of simply rejecting Judaism, Khazzoom is actively involved in redefining her Jewishness, currently working as program coordinator of the Jewish Multicultural Education Project when she is not singing and playing bass for her all-girls band. A left-wing religious Jew, Emily Wages takes on those progressive Jews who identify Judaism with oppression, patriarchy and xenophobia, while they honor other religions and cultures. With an upbeat foreword by noted Jewish scholar and feminist Susannah Heschel, this cutting-edge anthology is a welcome testament to how Jewish Gen-X women are finding their own distinctive voices.
Surprised by God: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Religion by Rabbi Danya Ruttenburg
Ruttenberg, who was recently ordained as a rabbi, decided at the age of 13 that she was an atheist. Then in the late 1990s, she experienced a spiritual awakening, taking what she describes as a winding, semi-reluctant path through traditional Jewish practice that eventually took me to the rabbinate. Ruttenberg writes that for her the work of the religious life has been about reconfiguration and reintegration, determining which parts she has outgrown and which could grow with her. The author, who lives in Los Angeles, lived for some time in Jerusalem. A tremendously satisfying memoir of spiritual awakening from the author of a variety of books and periodicals.
Yom Kippur A Go Go by Matthue Roth
From the World Bank riots (what can you do when the revolution starts on Shabbos?) to Thursday night tranny basketball in San Francisco’s Mission Dolores Park, Matthue takes readers on a journey through the queer and hip streets of urban America in his exuberant memoir, Yom Kippur a Go-Go. With humor and insight, Roth describes the tension between contemporary life and the demands of faith. He falls in love and in lust with a panoply of girls, both strictly kosher and determinedly secular, to the accompaniment of rabbinical lectures on modesty (“Boys are nothing but perverts and filthy animals!”).
The Fruit of Her Hands: The Story of Shira of Ashkenaz by Michelle Cameron
Crafting a richly textured, absorbing novel based on the life of her ancestor, renowned thirteenth-century Jewish scholar Meir ben Baruch of Rothenberg, Michelle Cameron paints a page-turning and deeply personal portrait of Judaism in medieval France and Germany. Imagined through the eyes of Rabbi Meir’s wife, Shira, this opulent drama reveals a devout but independent woman who struggles to preserve her religious traditions while remaining true to herself as she and her family witness the rise of anti-Semitism in Europe.
Matzoh Ball Gumbo by Marcie Cohen Ferris
Many traditional Southern foods–pulled-pork barbecue, crab cakes, fried oyster po’ boys, to name a few–violate traditional Jewish dietary laws, which forbid the consumption of pork and shellfish. What’s a Southern Jew to do? Anthropological historian Ferris (UNC-Chapel Hill) answers that question in a gustatory tour of the Jewish South. She uncovers many dishes that blend Jewish and Southern foodways (recipes included for such tasties as Temple Israel Brisket and Cornmeal-Fried Fish Fillets with Sephardic Vinagre Sauce). Ferris sees food as a symbol that encompasses the problem of how Jews live in a region dominated by Christians: “The most tangible way to understand Jewish history and culture in the South is at the dinner table.” Cynics will wonder if a Jewish kugel (noodle casserole) prepared in the South is really any different from kugel in Chicago. Ferris’s answer is an emphatic yes–because Jews in the South face different challenges than those in Chicago. Southern Jews must be more intentional about cooking that kugel and passing the recipe down from generation to generation. If this book were a restaurant, Michelin would award it two out of three stars: not absolutely first-rate, but “excellent cooking, worth a detour.”
Miriam’s Kitchen by Elizabeth Ehrlich
Food memoirs often delve into the meaning of life. This hardly surprises–memories are as essential to daily life as the food that sustains us. Miriam’s Kitchen blends recipes and food reminiscences with family narratives and observations about the author’s personal evolution as a Jew. Ehrlich weaves the stories from four generations of family life, punctuated with powerful and often tragic memories. While her mother-in-law, Miriam, is teaching her to make chicken livers with noodles, Ehrlich unexpectedly learns how Miriam, her mother, and husband survived a Nazi labor camp in Poland during the Holocaust. Using vivid and bare yet discreet words, she graphically tells what they suffered and the nightmares that still haunt them.
Ehrlich’s own story covers her transformation from a child whose family lit Sabbath candles but went boating on Yom Kippur, to an adult who chooses an Orthodox life marked by ambivalence about the rigors of being kosher and pride in what she is passing on to her children. Recipes for Honey Cake, Noodle Pudding, and many others are buried treasures hidden among Ehrlich’s intense words. Sadly omitted is a recipe for potato kugel. Her grandmother uses this tempting pudding to good-naturedly test, taunt, and ultimately as the means for accepting her daughter Selina’s non-Jewish fiancé into the family. Happily for us, 24 other tempting kosher recipes make up for this one missed dish. Miriam’s Kitchen is a gripping and gratifying memoir of food, life, tragedy, and family survival.
This is Where I Leave You by Jonathon Tropper
Few Jewish responses to tragedy resonate quite as powerfully as shiva, the week of mourning required of families after the passing of a close relative. Instead of a wake, the traditional Jewish response to death gathers the mourners together, has them sit on low stools, plies them with whitefish salad and lox, and waits until they begin to kibbitz about the dear departed. Jonathan Tropper, whose previous novels include The Book of Joe and Plan B, realized this ritual provides perfect fodder for a darkly comic family novel. He sets his latest, This Is Where I Leave You (Dutton, August) during a secular, e
stranged family’s week of mourning, adding in a failing marriage, an unexpected pregnancy, and plenty of other dysfunctions for good measure.
My Name is Asher Lev by Chaim Potok
Potok’s familiar style but an interesting story about struggling to follow one’s heart, one’s path and one’s faith.
Lovesong by Julius Lester
Lester, son of a black southern Methodist minister, writes of the eventful odyssey that culminated in his conversion to Judaism. The private journey was often at odds with his public life. As writer, radio commentator in New York and college professor at the University of Massachusetts, Lester’s outspoken and unconventional views often angered blacks as well as whites, and placed him in a political and philosophical fray between blacks and Jews. His spiritual quest, begun here with a lovingly detailed sketch of his southern heritage, took many turns, involving visits to sites of faith (Gethsemani Abbey, Wounded Knee, Shakertown) and intensive exploration of religious cultures, until he acknowledged the pull of the Jewish faith. He discusses his interracial marriage and fatherhood, and pays moving tribute to the fulfillment he finds in celebrating the Jewish faith
The Big Kahn by Neil Kleid (this is a graphic novel)
Rabbi David Kahn has lived a forty-year lie: he is not, nor has he ever been, Jewish. When at his funeral, the rabbi s grifter brother reveals the truth, it forces the Kahn family to struggle with grief and betrayal as their congregation examines their every move and question their very faith. His son, Rabbi Avi Kahn, the heir apparent, spirals down in an affair with his rebellious sister Lea s non-Jewish roommate. Lea rethinks the religion she s run from, strong enough to alter her father s life, while Eli the youngest Kahn inherits his father s long-forgotten legacy. Somehow, with the help of the uncle he never knew and his slowly re-awakening sister, he attempts to return faith and order to his family and community and reinstate his father s good name.
You Or Someone Like You by Chandler Burr
A love story rolled up in literature lessons. The narrator is the incandescent, opinionated, very well read, and professorial Anne. Born in England, the child of diplomats, Anne marries the Brooklyn-born and equally erudite Howard Rosenbaum, and they produce a very precocious son, Samuel. Anne’s natural sense of otherness, heightened by her Jewish in-laws’ lack of enthusiasm at their marriage, is further stretched when Howard accepts a studio executive position and moves the family to Los Angeles. Anne struggles to find a niche for herself, finally meeting success the moment she sets up a book club at the behest of a couple of Howard’s colleagues. Anne’s brilliance in running this salon fuels Hollywood’s boundless hunger for the next great screenplay. Soon Anne is dividing her book readers by film industry types, multiplying the number of groups, and her business is born. What of the love story? The differences of faith between Anne and Howard surface after their son returns from a trip to Israel, and Anne must work her literary magic to retrieve their love. If only for the lessons in linguistics and literature, this is recommended for all fiction collections.
This is the book I told you about a couple months ago where the author and I have a profound difference of opinion about religion at large and Judaism in particular but it sure does give you a lot to think about.
———
Let me know what you think.
Love,
Michelle